People subject to state power: the forensic pathologist’s critical role.
Deaths in custody and other deaths under state power demand an independent, complete, transparent and honest autopsy. Dr. Evan W. Matshes, NAAG Forensic.
Narrated by Evan W. Matshes, MD FRCPC · Medical Director & Chief Forensic Pathologist
People subject to state power (PSSP) are people whose liberty, safety or life was in the hands of the state when they died: during arrest, detention, imprisonment, restraint or transport, or through judicial execution, combat action or other state-sanctioned lethal action. Dr. Evan W. Matshes uses “people subject to state power” in place of the narrower “death in custody” because the same forensic questions arise wherever state power reaches. Deaths of state actors killed in the line of duty are a different category.
Why these deaths are different
In a PSSP death, the state is not only the investigator. It is part of the story. Families ask whether their loved one was failed. Communities ask whether they can trust those sworn to protect them. Officers ask whether they will be judged fairly. Every one of those questions runs through the autopsy.
What the forensic pathologist must provide
- Independence from police, from prosecutors, from the institution that held the person, and from the outcome anyone hopes for. Independence of the death investigation authority matters as much as independence of the pathologist.
- A complete examination, including high-quality, reviewable photography, postmortem imaging, and review of every minute of available body-worn camera and other video.
- Transparency. The examination is documented so thoroughly that any qualified expert, anywhere, can review it and reach their own conclusion. NAAG peer review tests every opinion for correctness, reasonableness and reviewer agreement.
- Honesty. The conclusion follows the evidence, whether it protects an officer or indicts a system.
Built on international standards
NAAG’s approach draws on the Minnesota Protocol on the Investigation of Potentially Unlawful Death, the Istanbul Protocol, and the National Association of Medical Examiners’ position on deaths in custody.
Trust is built one investigation at a time
Trust in justice is built one death investigation at a time, and it is lost the same way. When the state holds power over a person’s life, the investigation of their death must meet the highest standard of all. Because truth matters.
When a person dies in custody, during an arrest, in a cell, in restraints, the state is not only the investigator. It is part of the story.
We call them people subject to state power: anyone whose liberty, safety or life was in the hands of the state when they died. Arrested. Detained. Imprisoned. Restrained. Executed.
These are among the most consequential deaths a society investigates. Families ask whether their loved one was failed. Communities ask whether they can trust those sworn to protect them. Officers ask whether they will be judged fairly.
Every one of those questions runs through the autopsy.
The forensic pathologist must be independent: of police, of prosecutors, of the institution that held the person, and of the outcome anyone hopes for.
The examination must be complete, with high-quality photography, imaging, and review of every minute of body-worn camera video. And it must be documented so thoroughly that any qualified expert, anywhere, can review it and reach their own conclusion.
The conclusion must be honest, whether it protects an officer or indicts a system.
Trust in justice is built one death investigation at a time. It is lost the same way.
When the state holds power over a person’s life, the investigation of their death must meet the highest standard of all.
Because truth matters.
Start with a conversation.
Tell us who you are and, in general terms, what you need. The right member of our team will respond.
Please don't email case records or images. The case request form collects what we need to open your matter; we'll arrange secure transfer of records after that.
