Truth matters. Truth costs. Truth hurts.
People ask why NAAG exists. The short answer is because truth matters. The longer answer is that we have learned, at real cost, that telling the truth is the most important thing a forensic pathologist can do, and also the most expensive.
Evan W. Matshes, MD · Medical Director & Chief Forensic Pathologist
Truth matters.
In forensic pathology the truth is never abstract. A report decides whether a family learns why someone they loved has died. It can decide whether a person goes to prison, or goes home. It can decide whether a killer is found, or whether an innocent parent is made into a defendant. Every word spoken by a forensic pathologist carries weight.
That is why the truth cannot be shaded to suit the person who called, softened to make a meeting easier, or rounded off to keep a case moving. Each of those small conveniences is paid for by someone else, usually by someone who never had a say.
Truth costs.
I did not learn this from a textbook.
In 2011 I resigned as Assistant Chief Medical Examiner in Calgary, Alberta, because I could not keep practicing in a way I believed was wrong. What followed was more than a decade of allegations about my work. Every one of them was examined. A professional college dismissed a complaint. A court quashed a government review report, found that the process behind it had been unfair, and awarded me costs. A retired judge was later appointed to review the cases again. In February 2025 the Government of Alberta wrote to me to say that the allegations had been “proven to have been unfounded,” that they were retracted, and that I had been treated unfairly. It took fourteen years.
In Texas, after NAAG began performing autopsies under contract in 2018, we faced lawsuits and complaints to the state medical board. The lawsuits were dismissed, the court awarded us our fees and costs, and an appellate court affirmed. The Texas Medical Board closed its investigation in 2019 with no disciplinary action and no finding of wrongdoing.
I do not tell this to relitigate any of it. I tell it because it is the honest answer to why we work the way we do. Each time, what protected NAAG and me was not a title, a connection, or money. It was the work itself: documented, photographed, preserved, and open to anyone who wanted to check it. That is why every NAAG report is built to be checked, and why we keep the evidence for decades.
The cost is not only personal. Truth costs time, because the honest answer usually takes longer. It costs money, because doing every test the case needs is more expensive than doing the ones that confirm a first impression. And it costs comfort, because the truth is often not what anyone in the room was hoping to hear.
Truth hurts.
Sometimes it hurts a family. A cause of death can close a door that a family had hoped to keep open. Sometimes it hurts a theory: a prosecutor’s case does not hold together, or a defense team learns that the evidence supports the charge. We tell both sides the same thing, because the evidence is the same no matter who asks.
Sometimes the most honest answer is “undetermined,” and that disappoints everyone. We say it anyway when the evidence demands it.
And sometimes the truth heals. A mother who has blamed herself for years learns that nothing she did or failed to do caused her child’s death. That only happens if the answer was honest in the first place.
There is kindness in this work, and it matters a great deal. But the kindness is in how we tell the truth. It is never in changing it.
Why we pay it.
The alternative only looks less expensive. A false homicide costs an innocent person their freedom, their family and their name. A missed homicide costs the next victim. A comfortable answer to a grieving family costs them the truth they came for. Those costs are always paid in full, just not by the person who cut the corner.
NAAG was built so that the price of the truth is paid by us, and not by the families, the accused, or the public who rely on our work. That is the whole of our philosophy. Everything else is method.
Truth matters. Truth costs. Truth hurts. We tell it anyway.
Evan W. Matshes, MD FRCPC
Medical Director & Chief Forensic Pathologist, NAAG
Read our philosophy
Start with a conversation.
Tell us who you are and, in general terms, what you need. The right member of our team will respond.
San Diego, CA 92121
Please don't email case records or images. The case request form collects what we need to open your matter; we'll arrange secure transfer of records after that.
