Is neonatal autopsy still relevant? The question is why we stopped asking for it.
A recent study asked whether autopsy is still relevant for very preterm infants. The data answer the question plainly. The better question is why our hospitals and our medical culture have become so comfortable proceeding without it.
Medically reviewed by Evan W. Matshes, MD, FRCPC, D-ABP, Medical Director and Chief Forensic Pathologist · Updated
- In a 2026 study of very preterm infants, clinical and autopsy diagnoses agreed completely in only 27.3% of the 44 infants examined.
- Half of those autopsies produced major findings that the clinical team had not established.
- Not every discrepancy is an error. Autopsy also confirms good clinical judgment and corrects overdiagnosis.
- Some findings matter most to the family: they bear on the risk to future pregnancies and on genetic counselling.
- Fear of litigation is not a reason to avoid autopsy. Without it, an unavoidable death and a preventable one can look the same.
What did the study find?
Clinicians at a tertiary neonatal intensive care unit in Porto, Portugal reviewed every infant born before 32 weeks of gestation who was admitted to their unit over a 15-year period (2008 to 2022). Of 501 infants admitted, 73 died, and 44 of them (60.3%) had an autopsy. The study was published in Pediatrics & Neonatology in September 2026 (Noites et al., “Is neonatal autopsy still relevant? Insights from very preterm infants”).
The clinical diagnoses and the autopsy diagnoses agreed completely in only 27.3% of cases. Using the standard Goldman classification, the autopsy produced major findings in half of the infants (22 of 44). The autopsy also identified clinical overdiagnosis, added information the clinical team did not have, and revealed findings relevant to genetic counselling for the family.
Do these discrepancies mean the doctors were wrong?
Not necessarily, and it would be unfair to read the study that way. Very preterm infants are among the most difficult patients in medicine. Their illnesses are complex, their signs are subtle, and many examinations that would settle a diagnosis are too risky to perform on a baby who weighs less than a kilogram.
A properly performed autopsy is a truth-seeking activity. Sometimes it confirms excellent clinical judgment. Sometimes it reveals an understandable limitation of what could be known in life. Sometimes it exposes a consequential error. Physicians need to be willing to learn from all three, and the only way to learn any of them is to look.
Can imaging or clinical records take the place of an autopsy?
Clinical examination and diagnostic imaging are indispensable ways of investigating disease in the living, and postmortem imaging, including postmortem CT, has a real and growing place in death investigation. In some deaths, a careful external examination, imaging and a sound investigation answer the question safely and completely.
But in a very preterm infant, the questions are often about the lungs, the brain, the heart and the bowel at a microscopic level. The opportunity to examine organs and tissues directly after death, to establish what was present, what was missed and whether the clinical opinions were correct, is not something any record or scan fully reproduces. The Porto study is a reminder of how much is still learned when we look.
Why does it matter to families?
For parents, the cause of a baby’s death is rarely just a line on a certificate. It can explain what happened when nothing else does. It can lift a burden of self-blame that parents carry for years. And some findings, such as an inherited condition or a malformation, change what a family should know before a future pregnancy. That is why autopsy findings are so often relevant to genetic counselling and the health of relatives.
When a hospital autopsy is not offered or not available, families can still ask for one. A private autopsy by a board-certified forensic pathologist with pediatric expertise is one way to get answers when the questions are too important to leave unresolved.
What about fear of litigation?
Clinicians may understandably worry that an autopsy will be used against them. But if that concern discourages autopsy, we lose precisely the evidence needed to distinguish an unavoidable death from a preventable one, and to improve care for the next patient. An autopsy that confirms good care protects the people who provided it. An autopsy that reveals a problem is how medicine gets better.
What needs to change?
Of course autopsy is relevant. It never stopped being relevant. What has changed is the support for doing it well: the expertise, the funding and the institutional will. Medical culture needs to embrace autopsy again, with the resources to do it properly.
We should stop asking whether autopsy remains relevant and start asking why we have become so comfortable proceeding without it.
Source: Noites et al. Is neonatal autopsy still relevant? Insights from very preterm infants. Pediatrics & Neonatology, published online September 18, 2026 (journal pre-proof). Adapted from a LinkedIn post by Dr. Evan Matshes.
Frequently asked questions.
How often do autopsy findings differ from the clinical diagnosis in newborns?
It varies by study and setting. In a 2026 study of 44 very preterm infants, the clinical and autopsy diagnoses agreed completely in only 27.3% of cases, and half of the autopsies produced major findings.
Can a family request an autopsy for a baby who died in hospital?
Yes. Parents can ask the hospital for an autopsy. If one is not available, a family can arrange a private autopsy by a board-certified forensic pathologist.
Will an autopsy delay the funeral?
Usually only briefly. An autopsy can be coordinated with the family's funeral home.
Can an autopsy help with future pregnancies?
Sometimes. Findings such as inherited conditions or malformations can be relevant to genetic counselling and to planning a future pregnancy.
Talk to a forensic pathologist
Every case is different. Tell us about yours and we will tell you honestly what an examination or review can answer.
Start with a conversation.
Tell us who you are and, in general terms, what you need. The right member of our team will respond.
Please don't email case records or images. The case request form collects what we need to open your matter; we'll arrange secure transfer of records after that.
